So, the debate gets heated:^) This was too much fun to ignore:^) In my personal opinion, both pack rafts & kayaks are extremely capable vehicles for a vast variety of different types of whitewater. The difference:
Kayaks = faster
Pack rafts = turn faster
Kayaks = instant self-recover without swimming
Pack rafts = swim until it’s mellow enough to jump back in… or swim to shore if you can
Kayaks = break & need to be welded sometimes
Pack rafts = pop/slice/rip and need to be welded/patched sometimes
Kayaks = boof easier and much further away from danger at the base of drops
Pack rafts = auto boof but do not project far away from danger at the base of drops
Kayaks = back-ender (bandersnatch) occasionally
Pack rafts= back-ender (bandersnatch) frequently
Kayaks = heavy, but hikeable
Pack rafts = light and ridiculously easy to hike with
Kayaks = have the ability to punch holes under or on the foam pile
Pack rafts = stay on top of the foam pile, which means they can get sucked back into holes much easier
Kayaks = about $1,000
Pack rafts = about $1,000
Kayaks = take a more skilled paddler to navigate difficult water, but the difficulty of whitewater capable of being ran is much higher than a pack raft
Pack rafts = intermediates can paddle difficult runs, although they might not have developed the proper river reading skills and experience to make safe judgements on difficult water
Kayaks = ridiculous amounts of fun
Pack rafts = ridiculous amounts of fun
Kayaks = once they start cracking, your pretty much screwed and have to get another one
Pack rafts = once they rip, you can probably fix them and continue use a little longer than kayaks (unless you rip it like I did to Romans:^( sorry roman:^) I owe you one for that!
So, I guess what I’m getting at is that they are both capable vessels, one makes things easier some of the time and the other makes things easier the other “some” of the time. The only thing that concerns me is the fact that you can’t instantly self recover in a split-second combat roll (consistantly) in a packraft… which means pack rafters pushing the limits are going to start swimming some very dangerous whitewater. Kayakers generally are not even capable of paddling very dangerous whitewater without lots of experience and a solid roll, which means swimming is very rare. Of course there are exceptions of kayakers swimming, but good kayakers do not take near the amount of swims that good pack rafters take. So, just beware that if you are going to run difficult whitewater, whether you’re a kayaker or pack rafter, you need to know what you’re getting yourself into, study the dangers very carefully (just because it’s low doesn’t mean it’s safer), and have a recovery plan at all times in any difficult whitewater where swimming is potential.
There’s my 2 cents. Paddle on people!
Timmy J.
www.alaskawhitewater.org